They Didn't Ask Me (dr_phil_physics) wrote,
They Didn't Ask Me

  • Mood:

And You Thought You Understood The Significance

Link To An Awesome Post

jimhines Jim C. Hines posted a link to an entry from peri_peteia about the two Uhurus of Original Star Trek and the new Star Trek movie.

I love this essay, and I am thrilled to see that it has garnered 7 screens of really thoughtful comments.

When I wrote my review of Star Trek, I deliberately kept it short and didn't want to provide any spoilers, though lots of rumors and comments quickly spilled all over the Internet. So it's been out long enough that I can talk about the new Spock and Uhuru.

At first blush, having the two be an item -- and Uhuru telling Jim Kirk to stop being such a boy and grow up -- seemed a brilliant re-imagineering. And yet, even as I watched the movie twice, I had this nagging feeling that Uhuru, portrayed as being a rather brilliant communications cadet, might be pigeonholed as sleeping her way to success. And I don't think that was the point, or at least I'd be really disappointed if it was. Instead, I think that Uhuru was a totally competent and confident young woman, who managed to trade attractions with a brilliant, but enigmatic half-Vulcan instructor.

Not good military form to sleep with your instructor/supervisor. But when has Star Trek ever worried about good military form? I mean in this movie alone, it doesn't occur to anyone that on a ship the size of the Enterprise that there might be another officer aboard -- or dozens -- in the chain of command below Captain and First Officer who would be considered for command long before Mister Brash Young Thing.

Anyway, you should read the piece linked above. I found it brilliant and enlightening, and glad that I was linked to it by Jim.

Dr. Phil
Tags: opinion, reviews, science fiction, star trek

  • When East-West Isn't

    Wow. It was back on 12 September 2015 -- 56 days ago -- that I posted my last big writing update (DW) (LJ) on the YA series. So much for weekly…

  • End Of The High Stress Part Of The Week

    Whew. Thursday. October. Made it. Both my classes had their Exam 1s on Wednesday. So Sunday I had to write four exams -- both classes get a Form A…

  • Well That Hurdle Wasn't Too Bad

    Book 1 Edit Pass 6 (typos) page 380 [Beta 1 pp. 1-320] -- completed ‎09/‎12/‎2015 16:31:50 EDT Mrs. Dr. Phil finished her read of the Beta 1…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.