They Didn't Ask Me (dr_phil_physics) wrote,
They Didn't Ask Me
dr_phil_physics

  • Mood:

Finally The Great War in Film

Oh The Weather Outside Is Frightful

We're under a winter storm warning/watch/alert through 8pm Monday. Someone in West Michigan was complaining to Jim Wright in Alaska on Facebook that the weather has hardly been New Year's like, with temps in the 40s and no snow. Jim suggested "Yeah. See, you said it out loud. Foolish, foolish Michigander, you've now attracted the attention of the Lake Effect Gods. Good luck and Godspeed." The poster was in Whitehall MI -- they're in the 8-12"+ dump zone. Nice going.

Naturally we decided to go to a movie today.

The drive in was wet with the rain just turning into light snow, with some graupel bouncing off the back deck as we left. Winds of 20-40mph, gusting to sixty. The drive home was relatively clear, with some blowing snow. But US-31 was a wet slick icy road. The Bravada is AWD and we geared it down and drove at 25-40mph, instead of 55mph. Most of the other northbounders in our cohort agreed, but those who went out before us... well. In the five miles before turning east on M-45 we saw half a dozen vehicles off the road, most flipped over or on their sides and scads of police, fire, ambulance and tow trucks. Many turnout coat clad people either running around or wielding long cutting tools. Those newfangled ultra bright light bars on the police cars are very annoying to drive past in the dark, but they are visible from far away.

We got home safely and have been warm and comfy as the wind gusts and howls outside. Welcome to winter. Finally.

War Horse [PG-13]
Holland 8 Theatre #8, 3:15pm, 2×$6.75

Note that this is not a typo. The Holland 7 is a Goodrich theatre, while the Holland 8 was built as the Star Holland during a schism in the Loeks family which owns most of the other theatres we go to, and is now an AMC. We haven't been there in a couple of years, but the Holland 7 didn't have War Horse. The outlet mall you have to drive through to get to the Holland 8 has very few tenants -- driving through there on a windswept lightly snowing holiday is like some post apocalypse scene. The painted lines in their lot were very faded so people took up extra space, parked crookedly or cut me off from taking the last spots. I parked on the other side of the driveway, actually bothering to put on a parka before walking in, for once. Good call, given the increasing storm.

SF/F writer and professional puppeteer Mary Robinette Kowal auditioned for War Horse on Broadway -- which is so awesome, as we'd seen the puppets in action at the Tony Awards a couple of years ago. They used the play as the basis for the movie rather than the 1982 children's book, as the book apparently takes the horse's POV.

This is a beautiful film, with a stirring score by, guess who, John Williams. Do I detect that he stole themes from LOTR this time? (evil grin) The local review said this movie had qualities of movies shot fifty years ago. Doctor Zhivago comes to mind. But also some of the great old British country films, like Lassie. Though I'd wished the Devon farmers would've helped the struggling family more like the Amish, than treating it as a spectator sport. (evil grin)

World War I is so rarely portrayed in American cinema, but as I mentioned in the review of Hugo (DW), the Great War really damaged a generation in Europe.

War Horse is, of course, about a horse, Joey. The boy who trained him and the horse's impact on all who meet him. Joey is sort of like the main character of Kubrick's Barry Lyndon, being bantied back and forth between sides, but differs from the Kubrick character in that Joey (a) has a personality and (b) we care about him. And we see many sides on the human end -- English, French, German -- and if you're honest about it, the two warring armies shown are neither demonized.

As the war intrudes, you get something of the We'll Be Home By Christmas mentality, though no one actually says that chestnut. Knowing what we know now about WW I, the thought of a horse cavalry unit is totally out of place. But the unit is beautifully filmed and the horses are gorgeous. Seemingly swimming through a sea of tall grasses, just before battle... Ah...

I've never really seen a good depiction of a cavalry charge before. Spielberg has done it, though. And a horrible object lesson as to why they are obsolete. WW I is sometimes considered the first modern war, but it was really a disaster of collisions between technologies and infrastructure not quite ready for them. Which is why horses had to haul giant guns up hills or pull ambulances -- jobs done with motorized vehicles now.

And trench warfare. No Man's Land. Gas warfare. People need to see this, even if they don't understand.

Is the movie believable? Well, probably not in its total premise. According to Wikipedia, Britain sent a million horses to France and only 62,000 returned, with 10,000,000 horses estimated to be killed in the conflict.

Yet the story is still charming and moving. Typical Hollywood ratings, it's PG-13 as there's no bad language or sex. But there is killing. A lot of killing. At least it's in a historical context, so older kids should really be exposed to this. Wall to wall coverage of Iraq/Afghanistan wars and video games like the Call of Duty and Modern Warfare series do not give kids today the horror of WW I. Between War Horse and Saving Private Ryan, Steven Spielberg has created two of the great turn of the century war portrayals, between WWI and WW II.


Highly Recommended

Dr. Phil
Tags: movies, reviews, wwi
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments