They Didn't Ask Me (dr_phil_physics) wrote,
They Didn't Ask Me
dr_phil_physics

The Earlier Journey Continues

I Can't Believe I Didn't Post About The Hobbit Part I

Well, yes I can. It opened on Friday 14 December 2012 and I was smack in the middle of Grade-A-Thon and would've had to take a break from the papers, etc., yadda, and so on.

Had I written a review last year, it would've commented that Martin Freeman, Watson on BBC's Sherlock opposite Benedict Cumbersmaug or something like that (evil-grin), made a most excellent hobbit out of his element, first with an invading horde of dwarves in his pantry and then far from The Shire. The Hobbit as a book was always the lighter, more children's book to the massive intricacy of The Lord of the Rings and much more of a dangerous adventure. A fact some of those criticizing the movies fail to appreciate, that Peter Jackson is bringing it up to speed. (I once made the mistake of rereading The Hobbit after a re-read of the trilogy and found myself extraordinarily disappointed, instead of enjoying Bilbo's adventures in a time when he didn't know how bad things were going to get.)

While I liked it a lot, I did grow annoyed at the Indiana Jones and the Endless Unrealist Mine treatment of the battle with the goblins. And one can be forgiven for having to remember whether these are dwarves or Klingons. But Thorin Okenshield had a vast dignity to him and the backstory of Smaug's removal of the King Under the Mountain was good theatre, practically operatic.

And then, despite the some 168 minutes, it was over too soon.

So after some poor weather on Saturday, it was off on Sunday to Holland.

The Hobbit Part II: The Desolation of Smaug 3D [PG-13]
Holland 7 Theatre #5 11:55am 2x$9.50

Hobbit 2 is a better film than Hobbit 1. The first provides the setup, then stuff gets real in the second. I've heard complaints that there is no recap -- no introduction for those who didn't see Part I. I say tough. The Hobbit isn't that long a book that you can't keep the plot in mind. And they do open with a nice Twelve Months Ago scene in The Prancing Pony in Bree to get you up to speed. (The Kindle's auto correct of Bree to Beer is rather humorous under the circumstances.)

Chekhov's Black Arrow surfaces, which means it'll get played in the third act. Evangeline Lilly makes a fine elf. Those who complain that neither Lilly nor Orlando Bloom appeared in the book, should remember that there are a lot of things implied and characters never described in the book. That Jackson makes the connection with the son of the elf king and doesn't go with stock Central Casting for Just Another Male Elf is quite fine with me.

Overall, the 3D and special effects are lovely. And no one does giant stone figures like Jackson, whether the Argonath in LOTR or the stairs leading to the secret door under the mountain. I've a few issues with thermodynamic heating rates, but the Dragon is magnificent. I particular liked the rain of gold coins when Smaug gets up.

Whether under the Lonely Mountain or in the lair of the Necromancer, it doesn't look like Middle Earth is very ADA compliant -- there's a LOT of steep stairs. And entropy is a real bitch. How many stone stairs and bridges crumble as any of our heroes pass by? Reminds me of Sorcerer/The Wages of Fear -- you pass this way, but once, and there's no turning back. All that glory in ruin, turning to dust. It adds a great sadness and a great sense of history to Middle Earth. And also a feeling that it's populated by insane architects.

Of course, as the middle movie, The Desolation of Smaug pretty much has to end on a cliffhanger. Or rather Bilbo and the dwarves are left behind and the Dragon is heading off to eat a city. My physical therapist said she was upset that we saw Smaug fly away, but no desolation. I pointed out that the title phrase is uttered by wise old Balin when Bilbo asks about the ruins on the side of the Lonely Mountain. That's Dale -- the Desolation of Smaug. Pretty chilling, since we'd had some forewarning of Dale's fate.

BTW -- Yesterday I read in a Tor.com e-newsletter that there is an Extended Edition of The Hobbit Part I, and the reviewer felt that the additional thirteen minutes made it a better movie. I know that all three LOTR EEs were well worth the investment. Despite the sprawling length of the Peter Jackson movies, there's always stuff that ends on the cutting room floor which should have been included. I'll have to get ahold of the Blu-Ray Extended Editions at some point. We didn't do a pre-lab prior to seeing The Desolation of Smaug.

And why am I humming Leonard Nimoy all of a sudden?

Highly Recommended

Trailers: All 3D all the time... The Nut Job is an animated parody of the LOTR, sort of. I might actually watch this sometime. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 looks to jazz up the webcrawlers flying through the steel canyons of the Big City. Guessed I missed AS-M 1 somewhere along the line. Edge of Tomorrow is based on All You Need Is Kill -- a Japanese military science fiction novel by Hiroshi Sakurazaka. Nick Mamatas, the editor at Haikasoru/Viz Media, shepherded the English translation. He commented the other day that dispite whitewashing the characters and Tom Cruise, the trailer suggests they didn't do too much violence to the novel. Think Groundhog Day meets Starship Troopers. Definitely will see this one. There were other trailers, but I don't remember -- I think there was one other that was a strong possibility. Sort of Jason Bourne-esque.

Anyway, that was our Sunday afternoon. Good popcorn. And maybe that's the final word -- LOTR is epic, The Hobbit is popcorn. But like Holland 7, really good tasty popcorn with few bad kernels.

Dr. Phil
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments